Police in Ohio are on the search for the Peanut Butter Cup bandit who has stolen hundreds of dollars in candy from a gas station.

Maybe they should start rounding up everyone in town with the last name Reese.

Employees reported that a young man usually comes in after midnight and swipes Resse’s peanut butter cups. He then rushes out before the employee on duty can call police.

The store owner claims the suspect has stolen about $400 to $600 in that past few months.

The Morning Journal reports the latest theft happened early Tuesday morning. The police report indicates the man stole peanut butter cups and then went for some chips for dessert.

He was dressed in all black with a hood over his head.

A clerk tried to stop the man from exiting, but the suspect spun him around and fled from the scene.